- Lee Dwyze - "The Letter" I agreed with 3 of the judges and loved it! Simon didn't think it was a recording performance and it was corny.
- Paige Miles - "Against All Odds" HORRIBLE!! This time, I agreed with the judges. I feel bad for her but she's had her time in the spotlight. I thought she should have gone long ago.
- Tim Urban - "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" Not good! He was "smoozing" with the crowd like he was a rock fan. Paige is going to save him from going home though.
- Aaron Kelly - "I Don't Want to Miss A Thing" For a 17 year old, he is quite good and reminds me a lot of David Archuletta.
- Crystal Bowersox - "Bobby McGee" SOLID GOLD! My husband, Sonny called it last week - he said this was the song she should do. She's Janis Joplin made over. Can't wait till next week - she's already planning what she's going to do and said it was going to be different.
- Michael Lynche - "When A Man Loves A Woman" Perfect for him in my opinion.
- Andrew Garcia - "I Heard It Through The Grapevine" Not good .. again. Bottom 3
- Katie Stevens "Big Girls Don't Cry" What a great song for her! I think Myley really helped her out tonight.
- Casey James "Power of Love" He needs to drop the guitar and move around the stage more. I didn't care for his song choice but I thought he did a good job with it.
- Didi Benami " You're No Good" It was no good!
- Siobahn Magnus - "Superstition" Good as usual .... just not her best performance. I have to agree with Simon - the screeching at the end is getting old. I don't know about her hairdo tonight and can't believe not one of the judges commented on it!!
Paige Miles
Tim Urban
Andrew Garcia
Going home: Paige Miles
Top 3:
Crystal Bowersox
Mike Lynche
Katie Stevens