David vs David

Well, it's finally here - the final night to hear the two David's "duke" it out! It is obvious that David A is the judges choice to win...and they made it clear. Although, Simon was on Letterman Monday night and on Ellen Tuesday (I didn't see it - just read about it) and predicted David C. to win. The reality is that both Davids are great singers. I thought they both gave good performances. Cook's seemed a little more varied, but that is the type singer he appears to be. And I thought it showed something that he chose to sing three new songs unlike David A. who chose to go with Imagine which was already a winner with him this season. Talk about playing it safe! That's where Cook has it over Arch - he is not afraid to take chances and stretch himself. I thought Simon's remarks and even Randy's at the end of the night were a bit derogatory ("this round goes to David A."). Let America decide (after all we're the ones who are paying the for the CD's and downloads). I agree David A. is talented but he is sadly predictable. He needs some time to hone his skill and get to know how he wants to approach his career...otherwise he will face the same issues as Lohan, Spears...etc. This much fame is tough when you haven't found your own way yet.

I do love David A's voice, but do not see him as THE American Idol. Although in the event David Cook doesn't win, we can hope he will become just as successful as Daughtry. Losing didn't hurt him at all. Who woud have thought he would be touring with bon Jovi? Personally, I still prefer Cook but it’s hard to be upset if Archuleta takes it home. He has earned this. And we can always rationalize that, like Daughtry, Cook doesn’t need this win to succeed.

Here's what I've discovered about Wednesday's results show:

* Tomorrow’s finale will reprise that Celine/Dion live/dead duet with another live/dead combo.

* Each David got to pick their favorite out of the top 10 vote-getting songs in the songwriting contest. Good idea!

* Carrie Underwood will perform her latest single “Last Name”

Oh and that cute little kid from Tennessee who was living in his car ... Josiah Leming just missed the top 24 and has signed a record and publishing deal with Warner Brothers.

Well .... stay tune - until tomorrow night!!

Sharon